Out of the Shadows - The Legacy of Pineland Logo

An Early Warning About Institutions

Samuel Gridley Howe (1801-1876), Courtesy New Gloucester Historical Society

Samuel Gridley Howe (1801-1876)

In the beginning, Pineland, then the Maine School for the Feeble-Minded, was envisioned as a cottage-style facility with small living units providing a home-like setting where persons with developmental disabilities could learn social, educational, physical, and practical skills.

Instead, it quickly became a large facility where residents slept in cramped dormitories lined with cots, ate in large dining rooms, and had few opportunities to learn to be independent or live outside of such a setting.

Dr. Samuel Gridley Howe, who began one of the first programs for the “feeble minded” in Massachusetts in 1848, had determined within a decade that he made a mistake and warned against building large institutions.

Black and white photo of Dr. Samuel Gridley Howe from the mid-1800's - he is posed in a black suit with a white vest and shirt and a necktie similar to a bowtie. He is bearded with hair parted to one side that reaches his ears, and is looking off to the right of the camera.
Samuel Gridley Howe (1801-1876), Courtesy New Gloucester Historical Society

When he retired in 1874 from the facility he had founded, wrote to the trustees, describing institutions, describing them as “unnatural, undesirable, and very liable to abuse. We should have as few of them as possible, and those few should be kept as small as possible. The human family is the unit of society.”

Samuel Gridley Howe, Ceremonies on Laying the Cornerstone of the New York Institution for the Blind, 1825 1st picture: But, while thus noting with pleasure and even excusable pride, the humane impulses which prompt and which will carry forward the work, pardon me if I utter a word of warning. Good, intentions and kind impulses, do not necessarily lead to wise and truly humane measures.
Samuel Gridley Howe, Ceremonies on Laying the Cornerstone of the New York Institution for the Blind, 1825
Samuel Gridley Howe, Ceremonies on Laying the Cornerstone of the New York Institution for the Blind, 1825 - 2nd picture: There are several such already in this country; and unless we take heed there will be many more. Our people have rather a passion for public institutions, and when their attention is attracted to any suffering class, they make haste to organize one for its benefit. But instead of first carefully inquiring whether an institution is absolutely necessary, that is, whether there is no more natural and effectual manner of relieving the class; and afterwards, taking care that no vicious principle be incorporated into the establishment; they hastily build a great showy building, and gather within its walls a crowd of persons of like condition or infirmity; and organize a community where everything goes by clock-work and steam.
Samuel Gridley Howe, Ceremonies on Laying the Cornerstone of the New York Institution for the Blind, 1825
Return to Timeline
SCROLL DOWN